Thread - Crazy Arrows — LMI Sep Sudoku Test

@ 2011-09-12 10:46 AM (#5620 - in reply to #5515) (#5620) Top

Posts: 42

Country : United States

Ziti posted @ 2011-09-12 10:46 AM

Rohan, there were some exceptional puzzles in here and you deserve many congratulations for putting together such a clever set! Rarely does a sudoku really get the mind working so hard for so long, and for the designs to be so nifty is a nice touch as well. Thank you for the set.

Having said this, I found the Missing Arrow EXTREMELY difficult/impossible/guess-y (as did nearly everyone else) and the Parted Arrow felt similar to me (although 25 people solved it so I must have missed something, as usual). Until today, I had never ever torn up the page in a fit of absolute rage upon finding an error, so that must mean something! :) It is uncommon for a LMI sudoku test to have what feels like many necessary bifurcation steps, and in that sense I guess I am surprised. Of course it's very possible I just don't see the logic-based steps...

I will say that both Sum puzzles were terrific. The first one had a neat killer feel to it, and I felt that a necessary step was one I had never seen before in an Arrow puzzle. The second one had such a clean path to its solution that it will be remembered. A pity I spent 30-some minutes hitting my head against the desk on the three puzzles that stumped me midway through the test, else I might've gotten some points on #2!

@ 2011-09-12 10:49 AM (#5621 - in reply to #5515) (#5621) Top

akash.doulani

Posts: 157

Country : India

akash.doulani posted @ 2011-09-12 10:49 AM

i wish i had not attempted the symmetric arrow which ate up my valuable 25 minutes in which i could have solved atleast 2 more . but the puzzles were really good. thanks a lot rohan for such nice set of sudokus.

@ 2011-09-12 11:32 AM (#5622 - in reply to #5620) (#5622) Top

vopani

Posts: 739

Country : India

vopani posted @ 2011-09-12 11:32 AM

Ziti - 2011-09-12 10:46 AM

Rohan, there were some exceptional puzzles in here and you deserve many congratulations for putting together such a clever set! Rarely does a sudoku really get the mind working so hard for so long, and for the designs to be so nifty is a nice touch as well. Thank you for the set.

Having said this, I found the Missing Arrow EXTREMELY difficult/impossible/guess-y (as did nearly everyone else) and the Parted Arrow felt similar to me (although 25 people solved it so I must have missed something, as usual). Until today, I had never ever torn up the page in a fit of absolute rage upon finding an error, so that must mean something! :) It is uncommon for a LMI sudoku test to have what feels like many necessary bifurcation steps, and in that sense I guess I am surprised. Of course it's very possible I just don't see the logic-based steps...

Missing Arrow was tough and guesswork was obligatory. An interesting fact: Missing Arrow Sudoku is the least solved individual sudoku in any LMI sudoku test so far. So, kudos to Hideaki, Minfang, Murat, Thomas and Zafer.

I will say that both Sum puzzles were terrific. The first one had a neat killer feel to it, and I felt that a necessary step was one I had never seen before in an Arrow puzzle. The second one had such a clean path to its solution that it will be remembered. A pity I spent 30-some minutes hitting my head against the desk on the three puzzles that stumped me midway through the test, else I might've gotten some points on #2!

I had created 5 Arrow Sums Sudokus for this test and I had to include two of them. I think I chose wisely :-)

Thanks a lot, and I'm glad you enjoyed.

@ 2011-09-12 11:39 AM (#5623 - in reply to #5621) (#5623) Top

vopani

Posts: 739

Country : India

vopani posted @ 2011-09-12 11:39 AM

akash.doulani - 2011-09-12 10:49 AM

i wish i had not attempted the symmetric arrow which ate up my valuable 25 minutes in which i could have solved atleast 2 more . but the puzzles were really good. thanks a lot rohan for such nice set of sudokus.

Thats unfortunate, I'm sorry. Thanks :-)

@ 2011-09-12 6:18 PM (#5625 - in reply to #5623) (#5625) Top

harmeet

Posts: 87

Country : India

harmeet posted @ 2011-09-12 6:18 PM

Beautiful puzzles Rohan. All of them were gems. Congratulations!
I look forward to equally crazy arrows, not crazier, please!

@ 2011-09-12 9:28 PM (#5626 - in reply to #5625) (#5626) Top

vopani

Posts: 739

Country : India

vopani posted @ 2011-09-12 9:28 PM

harmeet - 2011-09-12 6:18 PM

Beautiful puzzles Rohan. All of them were gems. Congratulations!
I look forward to equally crazy arrows, not crazier, please!

Thanks Harmeet.

@ 2011-09-13 3:56 AM (#5627 - in reply to #5626) (#5627) Top

Fred76

Posts: 337

Country : Switzerland

Fred76 posted @ 2011-09-13 3:56 AM

Thanks for the fun tournament ! Very nice variations. Missing arrow and parted arrow made me completely crazy ! I lost a lot of time on these both grids and at the end I had some mistakes...
I've to solve these grids again and the symetric, which I have not yet began. Others were very beautiful and nice grids.

Fred

@ 2011-09-13 10:27 AM (#5628 - in reply to #5627) (#5628) Top

vopani

Posts: 739

Country : India

vopani posted @ 2011-09-13 10:27 AM

Fred76 - 2011-09-13 3:56 AM

Thanks for the fun tournament ! Very nice variations. Missing arrow and parted arrow made me completely crazy ! I lost a lot of time on these both grids and at the end I had some mistakes...
I've to solve these grids again and the symetric, which I have not yet began. Others were very beautiful and nice grids.

Fred

Thanks Fred.


	@ 2011-09-12 10:46 AM (#5620 - in reply to #5515) (#5620) Top
Ziti Posts: 42 Country : United States	Ziti posted @ 2011-09-12 10:46 AM Rohan, there were some exceptional puzzles in here and you deserve many congratulations for putting together such a clever set! Rarely does a sudoku really get the mind working so hard for so long, and for the designs to be so nifty is a nice touch as well. Thank you for the set. Having said this, I found the Missing Arrow EXTREMELY difficult/impossible/guess-y (as did nearly everyone else) and the Parted Arrow felt similar to me (although 25 people solved it so I must have missed something, as usual). Until today, I had never ever torn up the page in a fit of absolute rage upon finding an error, so that must mean something! :) It is uncommon for a LMI sudoku test to have what feels like many necessary bifurcation steps, and in that sense I guess I am surprised. Of course it's very possible I just don't see the logic-based steps... I will say that both Sum puzzles were terrific. The first one had a neat killer feel to it, and I felt that a necessary step was one I had never seen before in an Arrow puzzle. The second one had such a clean path to its solution that it will be remembered. A pity I spent 30-some minutes hitting my head against the desk on the three puzzles that stumped me midway through the test, else I might've gotten some points on #2!
	@ 2011-09-12 10:49 AM (#5621 - in reply to #5515) (#5621) Top
akash.doulani Posts: 157 Country : India	akash.doulani posted @ 2011-09-12 10:49 AM i wish i had not attempted the symmetric arrow which ate up my valuable 25 minutes in which i could have solved atleast 2 more . but the puzzles were really good. thanks a lot rohan for such nice set of sudokus.
	@ 2011-09-12 11:32 AM (#5622 - in reply to #5620) (#5622) Top
vopani Posts: 739 Country : India	vopani posted @ 2011-09-12 11:32 AM Ziti - 2011-09-12 10:46 AM Rohan, there were some exceptional puzzles in here and you deserve many congratulations for putting together such a clever set! Rarely does a sudoku really get the mind working so hard for so long, and for the designs to be so nifty is a nice touch as well. Thank you for the set. Having said this, I found the Missing Arrow EXTREMELY difficult/impossible/guess-y (as did nearly everyone else) and the Parted Arrow felt similar to me (although 25 people solved it so I must have missed something, as usual). Until today, I had never ever torn up the page in a fit of absolute rage upon finding an error, so that must mean something! :) It is uncommon for a LMI sudoku test to have what feels like many necessary bifurcation steps, and in that sense I guess I am surprised. Of course it's very possible I just don't see the logic-based steps... Missing Arrow was tough and guesswork was obligatory. An interesting fact: Missing Arrow Sudoku is the least solved individual sudoku in any LMI sudoku test so far. So, kudos to Hideaki, Minfang, Murat, Thomas and Zafer. I will say that both Sum puzzles were terrific. The first one had a neat killer feel to it, and I felt that a necessary step was one I had never seen before in an Arrow puzzle. The second one had such a clean path to its solution that it will be remembered. A pity I spent 30-some minutes hitting my head against the desk on the three puzzles that stumped me midway through the test, else I might've gotten some points on #2! I had created 5 Arrow Sums Sudokus for this test and I had to include two of them. I think I chose wisely :-) Thanks a lot, and I'm glad you enjoyed.
	@ 2011-09-12 11:39 AM (#5623 - in reply to #5621) (#5623) Top
vopani Posts: 739 Country : India	vopani posted @ 2011-09-12 11:39 AM akash.doulani - 2011-09-12 10:49 AM i wish i had not attempted the symmetric arrow which ate up my valuable 25 minutes in which i could have solved atleast 2 more . but the puzzles were really good. thanks a lot rohan for such nice set of sudokus. Thats unfortunate, I'm sorry. Thanks :-)
	@ 2011-09-12 6:18 PM (#5625 - in reply to #5623) (#5625) Top
harmeet Posts: 87 Country : India	harmeet posted @ 2011-09-12 6:18 PM Beautiful puzzles Rohan. All of them were gems. Congratulations! I look forward to equally crazy arrows, not crazier, please!
	@ 2011-09-12 9:28 PM (#5626 - in reply to #5625) (#5626) Top
vopani Posts: 739 Country : India	vopani posted @ 2011-09-12 9:28 PM harmeet - 2011-09-12 6:18 PM Beautiful puzzles Rohan. All of them were gems. Congratulations! I look forward to equally crazy arrows, not crazier, please! Thanks Harmeet.
	@ 2011-09-13 3:56 AM (#5627 - in reply to #5626) (#5627) Top
Fred76 Posts: 337 Country : Switzerland	Fred76 posted @ 2011-09-13 3:56 AM Thanks for the fun tournament ! Very nice variations. Missing arrow and parted arrow made me completely crazy ! I lost a lot of time on these both grids and at the end I had some mistakes... I've to solve these grids again and the symetric, which I have not yet began. Others were very beautiful and nice grids. Fred
	@ 2011-09-13 10:27 AM (#5628 - in reply to #5627) (#5628) Top
vopani Posts: 739 Country : India	vopani posted @ 2011-09-13 10:27 AM Fred76 - 2011-09-13 3:56 AM Thanks for the fun tournament ! Very nice variations. Missing arrow and parted arrow made me completely crazy ! I lost a lot of time on these both grids and at the end I had some mistakes... I've to solve these grids again and the symetric, which I have not yet began. Others were very beautiful and nice grids. Fred Thanks Fred.