|
|
Administrator
![2000](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/2000.gif) ![1000](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/1000.gif) ![500](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/500.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : India |
Logic Masters India announces DWBH — LMI October Puzzle Test #3
Dates : 26 th — 28 th October
Instruction Booklet & Submission : Link
Author : Matej Uher (muhorka)
Length : 75 minutes
|
|
auroux
Posts: 145
![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : France | auroux posted @ 2013-10-23 11:53 PM It's very minor, but:
- the example and solution for "Rectangles?" don't match (both are valid puzzles but slightly different ones :-)
- the "Tapa?" puzzle doesn't have a unique solution. One could e.g. add a "?" in row 4 column 2 to make it unique.
|
|
swaroop2011
![](/forum/profile/get-photo.asp?memberid=1802&type=profile&rnd=867) Posts: 668
![500](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/500.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : India | classics : wow looking forward to it :) |
|
Administrator
![2000](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/2000.gif) ![1000](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/1000.gif) ![500](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/500.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : India | | | AnnouncementsTest length is changed to 75 minutesUpdated version of IB uploaded with fixed examples of Tapa & fixed solution of RectanglesPoints table added to IB.Total points is 750, bonus points changed to 10 points per minute savedPassword protected puzzle booklet has 8 pages (no cover page).
|
|
|
motris
Posts: 199
![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : United States | motris posted @ 2013-10-26 7:41 AM Cute test. I wish I was better at kakuro.
When there is a large theme throughout a test, I often wonder if some of the puzzles will be adversely affected. Here I decided: don't worry, just be happy that there were many fun ones to do. |
|
achan1058
Posts: 80
![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : Canada | How balanced do you think the puzzle types of this test were? | Perfectly balanced | | What was your opinion of the distribution of easy/hard puzzles? | Just right | | What did you think about the puzzle quality of the test? | Fairly Nice | | What was your opinion about the answer key extraction? | Perfect answer keys | | How did you feel about the length / time limit for this test? | Just right | | Of the puzzles you solved/attempted, how well did the point values reflect the difficulty? | Many puzzles were worth too much or too little | | What was your opinion of the booklet formatting and printing? | I have a different complaint | |
Maybe it's just my laser printer, but the given lines are dark enough that I have trouble drawing lines on top of the given lines in the slitherlink and fillomino. P.S. I got destroyed, especially considering my performance of the classics in the WPC. Edited by achan1058 2013-10-26 8:38 AM
|
|
yureklis
Posts: 183
![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : Turkey | Lovely test! I had trouble with the Kakuro, nearly 30 minutes, just tried to put digits in the top of the grid, but there was always mistakes, then I figured it out, I had put a wrong digit in the middle of the grid :) Anyway, thanks for the test Matej |
|
prasanna16391
Posts: 1800
![1000](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/1000.gif) ![500](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/500.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) Country : India | yureklis - 2013-10-26 1:14 PM
Lovely test! I had trouble with the Kakuro, nearly 30 minutes, just tried to put digits in the top of the grid, but there was always mistakes, then I figured it out, I had put a wrong digit in the middle of the grid :)
Hah. I had exactly the same experience with the Kakuro. If your mistake was on the middle left then we must be solving twins. ![](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/emoticons/smile_tongue.gif) |
|
yureklis
Posts: 183
![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : Turkey | prasanna16391 - 2013-10-26 1:28 PM
yureklis - 2013-10-26 1:14 PM
Lovely test! I had trouble with the Kakuro, nearly 30 minutes, just tried to put digits in the top of the grid, but there was always mistakes, then I figured it out, I had put a wrong digit in the middle of the grid :)
Hah. I had exactly the same experience with the Kakuro. If your mistake was on the middle left then we must be solving twins. ![](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/emoticons/smile_tongue.gif)
: ) ehehe yes, it was. So my puzzle brother, how is your finger? |
|
prasanna16391
Posts: 1800
![1000](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/1000.gif) ![500](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/500.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) Country : India | yureklis - 2013-10-26 2:23 PM
prasanna16391 - 2013-10-26 1:28 PM
yureklis - 2013-10-26 1:14 PM
Lovely test! I had trouble with the Kakuro, nearly 30 minutes, just tried to put digits in the top of the grid, but there was always mistakes, then I figured it out, I had put a wrong digit in the middle of the grid :)
Hah. I had exactly the same experience with the Kakuro. If your mistake was on the middle left then we must be solving twins. ![](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/emoticons/smile_tongue.gif)
: ) ehehe yes, it was. So my puzzle brother, how is your finger?
Exactly the same as how you saw it during the closing ceremony. Its a good thing its not my right finger, or I'd be unemployed for a month ![](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/emoticons/smile_omg.gif) and some future LMI plans would be canceled too. Says something about the risks we puzzlers take. ![](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/emoticons/smile_angel.gif) |
|
achan1058
Posts: 80
![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : Canada | prasanna16391 - 2013-10-26 2:28 AM
yureklis - 2013-10-26 1:14 PM
Lovely test! I had trouble with the Kakuro, nearly 30 minutes, just tried to put digits in the top of the grid, but there was always mistakes, then I figured it out, I had put a wrong digit in the middle of the grid :)
Hah. I had exactly the same experience with the Kakuro. If your mistake was on the middle left then we must be solving twins. ![](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/emoticons/smile_tongue.gif)
Same thing happened here too, though I solved it after the test was over. |
|
chaotic_iak
![](/forum/profile/get-photo.asp?memberid=2069&type=profile&rnd=80) Posts: 241
![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : Indonesia | How balanced do you think the puzzle types of this test were? | Perfectly balanced | | What was your opinion of the distribution of easy/hard puzzles? | Just right | | What did you think about the puzzle quality of the test? | Very nice | | What was your opinion about the answer key extraction? | Mostly perfect answer keys | | How did you feel about the length / time limit for this test? | Just right | | Of the puzzles you solved/attempted, how well did the point values reflect the difficulty? | Most puzzles were worth the right amount | | What was your opinion of the booklet formatting and printing? | Just right | |
|
|
ukonet
Posts: 9
Country : Turkey | ukonet posted @ 2013-10-26 5:59 PM How balanced do you think the puzzle types of this test were? | Fairly balanced | | What was your opinion of the distribution of easy/hard puzzles? | Just right | | What did you think about the puzzle quality of the test? | Fairly Nice | | What was your opinion about the answer key extraction? | Mostly perfect answer keys | | How did you feel about the length / time limit for this test? | A bit too few puzzles | | Of the puzzles you solved/attempted, how well did the point values reflect the difficulty? | Most puzzles were worth the right amount | | What was your opinion of the booklet formatting and printing? | Just right | |
|
|
TiiT
Posts: 139
![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : Estonia | TiiT posted @ 2013-10-26 6:49 PM How balanced do you think the puzzle types of this test were? | Perfectly balanced | | What was your opinion of the distribution of easy/hard puzzles? | Just right | | What did you think about the puzzle quality of the test? | Fairly Nice | | What was your opinion about the answer key extraction? | Perfect answer keys | | How did you feel about the length / time limit for this test? | Just right | | Of the puzzles you solved/attempted, how well did the point values reflect the difficulty? | Most puzzles were worth the right amount | | What was your opinion of the booklet formatting and printing? | Just right | |
|
|
kishy72
Posts: 419
![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) Country : India | kishy72 posted @ 2013-10-26 7:58 PM How balanced do you think the puzzle types of this test were? | Very skewed | | What was your opinion of the distribution of easy/hard puzzles? | Too many hard puzzles | | What did you think about the puzzle quality of the test? | Very nice | | What was your opinion about the answer key extraction? | Mostly perfect answer keys | | How did you feel about the length / time limit for this test? | Way too many puzzles (too little time) | | Of the puzzles you solved/attempted, how well did the point values reflect the difficulty? | Most puzzles were worth the right amount | | What was your opinion of the booklet formatting and printing? | Just right | |
An enticing Puzzle test covering all the basic puzzle types ,just good enough to lure persons who are relatively new and who grapple with new puzzle types to take the test. But alas to what use is that???The test has been timed so poorly that i felt only a mad adrenaline rush during the course of the test rather than actually enjoying the test.The experience would have been even worse had the test been timed for 60 mins.Thankfully ,a better sense prevailed and because of that extra 15 mins i was able to complete the Kakuro and submit it within time.It would have been an utter waste of effort from my part if the test were for 60mins. This test clearly demonstrates to me that its intended purpose is only to test a minority of lightning quick solvers at the cost of taking the fun out of a majority of slow solvers (including me ).After all what harm would have come out if the test had been timed for 120 mins, other than perhaps more solvers completing the test and a majority of the slower puzzlers attempting a lot more puzzles.But isn't that the actual purpose of any LMI test ? I feel so disappointed now because the excitement that i got after seeing so many familiar puzzle types in the IB has just been killed.Now i dont even feel like seeing the rest of the 13 uncompleted puzzles let alone attempt it.The time factor has skewed my feedback in other categories as well.It has forced me to say i was hoping for better (which is certainly true in my case )regarding the overall opinion of the test.In the end it seems i have to console myself by saying Don't worry ,Be happy in which the latter seems highly unlikely to happen. Edited by kishy72 2013-10-26 8:01 PM
|
|
achan1058
Posts: 80
![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : Canada | I can certainly see your point. It would be nice to once in a while to have a test that even someone like me can finish, even if that means the likes of Palmer and Ulrich will finish in 1/2 the allotted time. |
|
An LMI player
| An LMI player posted @ 2013-10-26 9:17 PM How balanced do you think the puzzle types of this test were? | A bit skewed | | What was your opinion of the distribution of easy/hard puzzles? | Too many hard puzzles | | What did you think about the puzzle quality of the test? | Fairly Nice | | What was your opinion about the answer key extraction? | Perfect answer keys | | How did you feel about the length / time limit for this test? | Way too many puzzles (too little time) | | Of the puzzles you solved/attempted, how well did the point values reflect the difficulty? | Most puzzles were worth the right amount | | What was your opinion of the booklet formatting and printing? | Just right | |
|
|
prasanna16391
Posts: 1800
![1000](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/1000.gif) ![500](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/500.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) Country : India | achan1058 - 2013-10-26 9:01 PM
I can certainly see your point. It would be nice to once in a while to have a test that even someone like me can finish, even if that means the likes of Palmer and Ulrich will finish in 1/2 the allotted time.
Well, We DO have Beginners' Contests for that. Admittedly, we've had just one Beginners' Puzzle Contest so far which was probably on the tough side, but we are working on a format there and it will be here in the future. Give us time : ) Monthly tests are designed to have a world championship-related structure in terms of difficulty and finish-ability. The typical guideline for the monthly tests, barring special ones like sprint tests, etc. is that about 3-4 people should finish the test. Its fine to have an opinion that maybe that structure should be more lenient sometimes, but the problem comes when its pinpointed to this test just because of individual expectations that "classic puzzles = easy puzzles".
My main problem with Kishore's criticism is that it wasn't said that this test would contain easier puzzles, or that it would be more finish-able than others. This test was only said to be filled with classic puzzles, which it was. So its not like the author claimed something wrong. Its really unfair to criticize saying you expected there to be easier/finishable puzzles, especially when you yourself say that the Kakuro (highest pointer ) is one you attempted. |
|
rvarun
Posts: 268
![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : India | rvarun posted @ 2013-10-26 10:01 PM There were quite many low and medium pointer puzzles in the test. I guess solving these puzzles will give more confidence to everyone. Since kakuro was the highest pointer we can easily assume that it ll take more time. So it must be the participant's choice of solving order. Personally i feel the puzzles were too good and kudos to Matej. Definitely i ll try solving the puzzles offline as classics will be a good platform to start from the scratch. Thanks to Matej again for the Classics set.
Edited by rvarun 2013-10-26 10:16 PM
|
|
An LMI player
| An LMI player posted @ 2013-10-27 12:49 AM How balanced do you think the puzzle types of this test were? | Fairly balanced | | What did you think about the puzzle quality of the test? | Fairly Nice | | What was your opinion about the answer key extraction? | Answer keys could have been better | | How did you feel about the length / time limit for this test? | A bit too many puzzles | | Of the puzzles you solved/attempted, how well did the point values reflect the difficulty? | Many puzzles were worth too much or too little | | What was your opinion of the booklet formatting and printing? | Just right | |
|
|
An LMI player
| An LMI player posted @ 2013-10-27 1:37 AM How balanced do you think the puzzle types of this test were? | Fairly balanced | | What was your opinion of the distribution of easy/hard puzzles? | Just right | | What did you think about the puzzle quality of the test? | Average | | What was your opinion about the answer key extraction? | Answer keys could have been better | | How did you feel about the length / time limit for this test? | Just right | | Of the puzzles you solved/attempted, how well did the point values reflect the difficulty? | Most puzzles were worth too much or too little | | What was your opinion of the booklet formatting and printing? | Just right | |
|
|
An LMI player
| An LMI player posted @ 2013-10-27 2:39 AM How balanced do you think the puzzle types of this test were? | Fairly balanced | | What was your opinion of the distribution of easy/hard puzzles? | Just right | | What did you think about the puzzle quality of the test? | Fairly Nice | | What was your opinion about the answer key extraction? | Mostly perfect answer keys | | How did you feel about the length / time limit for this test? | Just right | | Of the puzzles you solved/attempted, how well did the point values reflect the difficulty? | Many puzzles were worth too much or too little | | What was your opinion of the booklet formatting and printing? | Just right | |
|
|
An LMI player
| An LMI player posted @ 2013-10-27 2:50 AM How balanced do you think the puzzle types of this test were? | Fairly balanced | | What was your opinion of the distribution of easy/hard puzzles? | Just right | | What did you think about the puzzle quality of the test? | Fairly Nice | | What was your opinion about the answer key extraction? | Perfect answer keys | | Of the puzzles you solved/attempted, how well did the point values reflect the difficulty? | Many puzzles were worth too much or too little | | What was your opinion of the booklet formatting and printing? | Just right | |
|
|
auroux
Posts: 145
![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : France | auroux posted @ 2013-10-27 4:37 AM Wow, that's crazy! I also spent lots of time on Kakuro due to a wrong digit at the left of the grid...Anyway: fun puzzles!Denis |
|
murat
Posts: 2
Country : Turkey | murat posted @ 2013-10-27 11:54 AM The test has been timed so poorly that i felt only a mad adrenaline rush during the course of the test rather than actually enjoying the test.
I think kishy72 has a point. Setting the duration of a test such that only the top solvers can finish is a poor decision when instant grading is available. Why is not the test longer so that more people can enjoy all puzzles?
With the current test length the selection of puzzles is very important for an average solver. I think it should not be that important unless you want to increase the influence of the luck factor in the rankings. |
|
prasanna16391
Posts: 1800
![1000](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/1000.gif) ![500](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/500.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) Country : India | I still don't understand this, because its like every test. For anyone who can't finish a test, puzzle selection matters. Thats not luck. It would be luck if points distribution was not given and someone went and attempted the Kakuro thinking it to be easy or the Akari thinking they'd get more points for it. But its known which are the lower pointers and the higher pointers, its upto the solver to select the puzzles in a way to optimize their performance. Thats a part of competing. Every Monthly test barring exceptions is typically designed so that the top 3-4 players can finish and there's a few easy puzzles for the rest. In fact, this test has more easy puzzles than others, in my opinion. Its not like 75 minutes is an unheard of time, in fact the ever successful TVCs are also of 75 minutes.
The guidelines LMI gives to the authors was followed here. There were a few easy puzzles, and it was finishable for top solvers. There was never claims that it would be otherwise. Why pinpoint this test on being timed poorly, when it followed the general guidelines?
Obviously, if the discussion is that the general guidelines themselves should be re-visited, then thats a completely different matter. I'll again point to the existence of Beginners' Contests and the need to make the distinction that the Monthly tests are set based on general WPC difficulty and finish-ability. |
|
rvarun
Posts: 268
![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : India | rvarun posted @ 2013-10-27 12:31 PM This is how LMI tests work. Top few solvers solving all puzzles in given time, be it 120 mins or 75 mins. This test is same as any other LMI test. I dont find any difference in it in my experience of LMI tests. The same goes for sudoku tests also. There were sudoku tests with 60 or 75 mins. But the same feedbacks does not come there. |
|
achan1058
Posts: 80
![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : Canada | It's probably because this is a classic, and people (incorrectly) assumes that a classic contest should be easier. While I have done enough puzzle contests to know better, I can't say I didn't have the hope that it will be a bit easier than usual myself, especially right after the WPC.
For the record, my previous post was not directed at this contest in particular, but the contest scheme in general. I think we can have a few "Round 8"'s once in a while.
On another note, there is no efficient mechanism for someone to check their answers if they decide to continue the contest after it is over. The answer keys aren't displayed until after the whole duration is over, and you can't use the submit form to check anymore. Can this be improved upon?
Edited by achan1058 2013-10-27 3:07 PM
|
|
prasanna16391
Posts: 1800
![1000](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/1000.gif) ![500](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/500.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) Country : India | achan1058 - 2013-10-27 2:51 PM
It's probably because this is a classic, and people (incorrectly) assumes that a classic contest should be easier. While I have done enough puzzle contests to know better, I can't say I didn't have the hope that it will be a bit easier than usual myself, especially right after the WPC.
For the record, my previous post was not directed at this contest in particular, but the contest scheme in general. I think we can have a few "Round 8"'s once in a while.
On another note, there is no efficient mechanism for someone to check their answers if they decide to continue the contest after it is over. The answer keys aren't displayed until after the whole duration is over, and you can't use the submit form to check anymore. Can this be improved upon?
For Round 8, I'll compare it to Puzzle Marathon. Instead of one finish-able connected large puzzle, it is a bunch of large puzzles that are mostly finish-able in time by many folks. So there IS something like that once in a while.
Another point is, 6 people have already finished DWBH and its only midway through Sunday. Many have come close to finishing. So I think it IS actually more finish-able, so its funny its getting criticized for poor timing. Its important to keep a standard in normal tests, because if you're extending it to say top 20 finish-ability, you'll never please everyone anyway, and then it becomes inconsistent for no reason. erring towards say 8-10 once in a while is fine, but it shouldn't be expected unless explicitly mentioned.
As for the entering answer keys, thats apparently been unintentionally allowed this time. Those who didn't close the page upon submission would've found out that the "Submit all answers" key still works to check answers. We didn't realize this till 2-3 people began trying and actually entered keys beyond 75 minutes. You're right, maybe this is a good thing to keep in general, at least when Instant Grading is available. |
|
achan1058
Posts: 80
![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : Canada | Oh, by Round 8, I meant how easy that round was, not the structure of the round itself. At least 1/3 of the room have completely finished that round.
Anyways, thanks for looking into whether you can keep the submit button.
Edited by achan1058 2013-10-27 4:13 PM
|
|
prasanna16391
Posts: 1800
![1000](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/1000.gif) ![500](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/500.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) Country : India | achan1058 - 2013-10-27 4:13 PM
Oh, by Round 8, I meant how easy that round was, not the structure of the round itself. At least 1/3 of the room have completely finished that round.
I meant it in the same way. The Puzzle Marathon Puzzles are finished by a good number of people too. Me in my capacity at around upper-mid table (37th ) finished all the puzzles within normal time in this year's marathon. I'm sure many people finished at least some of them within the 60 minutes of normal time.
The reason I compared structures is because it works in that structure, because solving the puzzle in itself is the challenge, contrasting to solving a bunch of puzzles in a controlled time environment like normal rounds. |
|
yureklis
Posts: 183
![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : Turkey | How balanced do you think the puzzle types of this test were? | Perfectly balanced | | What was your opinion of the distribution of easy/hard puzzles? | Just right | | What did you think about the puzzle quality of the test? | Very nice | | What was your opinion about the answer key extraction? | Mostly perfect answer keys | | How did you feel about the length / time limit for this test? | Just right | | What was your opinion of the booklet formatting and printing? | Just right | |
|
|
debmohanty
![](/images/LMINewLogo.png)
![1000](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/1000.gif) ![500](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/500.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : India | achan1058 - 2013-10-26 9:01 PM
It would be nice to once in a while to have a test that even someone like me can finish, even if that means the likes of Palmer and Ulrich will finish in 1/2 the allotted time. I agree with that comment, it is good to have all kinds of contests. If we go by the poll results here, there are certainly many takers of Sprint tests. Unfortunately, we just had only one more sprint test in 2012 after the first one.
While Marathons are comparable to Sprint tests in terms of finish-ability, each kind of contests has its own fun and challenges. So I don't think one of them should/can replace the other.
|
|
kishy72
Posts: 419
![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) Country : India | kishy72 posted @ 2013-10-27 7:24 PM rvarun - 2013-10-27 12:31 PM
This is how LMI tests work. Top few solvers solving all puzzles in given time, be it 120 mins or 75 mins. This test is same as any other LMI test. I dont find any difference in it in my experience of LMI tests. The same goes for sudoku tests also. There were sudoku tests with 60 or 75 mins. But the same feedbacks does not come there.
For your information for the last 15 or so months that i have been a part of LMI ,I dont remember any sudoku test in which the time duration was for 60 mins except LMI Screen Test.I had expressed my feedback there too though for a different reason.So it is not that in only puzzle tests that feedbacks of these sort occur.
And please dont equate sudokus and puzzles on an equal platform.If you call say a random person from a group of persons and ask him to choose from a sudoku and a star battle or a sudoku and a fillomino or so on ,it is very probable that he/she will possess the skills required to complete the sudoku rather than the puzzle.This is because sudokus are universally popular and well known.So basically what i m trying to put forth through this is that given an LMI test with a short time duration ,it is more likely that people will solve a lot more sudokus than a lot more puzzles within the time frame which in turn minimizes the short time factor to an extent in case of sudoku tests not to mention the fact that it has not occured so far in a LMI sudoku test.I'l clarify this too.My feedback has got nothing to do with the quality of the puzzles which were on an absolutely high level as usual.It is only the timing of the test that has let me down. |
|
achan1058
Posts: 80
![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : Canada | debmohanty - 2013-10-27 8:10 AM
achan1058 - 2013-10-26 9:01 PM
It would be nice to once in a while to have a test that even someone like me can finish, even if that means the likes of Palmer and Ulrich will finish in 1/2 the allotted time. I agree with that comment, it is good to have all kinds of contests. If we go by the poll results here, there are certainly many takers of Sprint tests. Unfortunately, we just had only one more sprint test in 2012 after the first one.
While Marathons are comparable to Sprint tests in terms of finish-ability, each kind of contests has its own fun and challenges. So I don't think one of them should/can replace the other.
That's what I like to hear. I am surprised that wasn't more of these. In fact, that one happened long before I started doing contests on LMI. |
|
An LMI player
| An LMI player posted @ 2013-10-27 10:07 PM How balanced do you think the puzzle types of this test were? | Fairly balanced | | What was your opinion of the distribution of easy/hard puzzles? | Just right | | What did you think about the puzzle quality of the test? | Very nice | | What was your opinion about the answer key extraction? | Mostly perfect answer keys | | How did you feel about the length / time limit for this test? | Just right | | Of the puzzles you solved/attempted, how well did the point values reflect the difficulty? | Most puzzles were worth the right amount | | What was your opinion of the booklet formatting and printing? | Just right | |
|
|
debmohanty
![](/images/LMINewLogo.png)
![1000](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/1000.gif) ![500](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/500.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : India | achan1058 - 2013-10-27 10:00 PM
That's what I like to hear. I am surprised that wasn't more of these. In fact, that one happened long before I started doing contests on LMI. Well, there is none planned at the moment as well. That also means, potential test authors know what they can target to write. |
|
wicktroll
Posts: 16
Country : Hungary | How balanced do you think the puzzle types of this test were? | Perfectly balanced | | What was your opinion of the distribution of easy/hard puzzles? | Just right | | What did you think about the puzzle quality of the test? | Fairly Nice | | What was your opinion about the answer key extraction? | Answer keys could have been better | | How did you feel about the length / time limit for this test? | A bit too many puzzles | | Of the puzzles you solved/attempted, how well did the point values reflect the difficulty? | Most puzzles were worth the right amount | | What was your opinion of the booklet formatting and printing? | Just right | |
|
|
murat
Posts: 2
Country : Turkey | murat posted @ 2013-10-28 12:51 AM Why pinpoint this test on being timed poorly, when it followed the general guidelines?
To make it clear, my comment was not particularly about this test. I think any test with instant grading can last longer than usual to have more fair ranking of the average solvers. If instant grading were not available the current duration of the test would be perfect, because making it longer would cause early finishers to risk losing a lot of bonus points due to possible mistakes. However, I don't see any disadvantages of making the test longer when instant grading is available. |
|
motris
Posts: 199
![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : United States | motris posted @ 2013-10-28 2:06 AM Just my two cents:
Team USA had a similar discussion to this at the recent WPC -- how rounds can feel much friendlier and fairer by letting more solvers finish. We agreed that an underappreciated feature of Instant Grading is that it really means you can now run any test indefinitely with some form of "Twist" scoring (here, that might be 80% after 60 minutes, 50% after 90 minutes) because solvers are entering solutions throughout the test.
I would not have minded this test running more like the WPC Mini Marathon or LMI Puzzle Marathon tests which seem to be the best solving format for all solvers from beginners to experts. It certainly removes some of the frustrations from puzzle selection, puzzle scoring, and round timing. Of course rules decisions should be left to the authors and LMI organizers, but I wonder if a general trend towards "friendlier" puzzle sets and rules is one way to help grow the audience of competitors.
Edited by motris 2013-10-28 2:09 AM
|
|
Joo M.Y
Posts: 72
![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : South Korea | Joo M.Y posted @ 2013-10-28 7:18 PM How balanced do you think the puzzle types of this test were? | Perfectly balanced | | What was your opinion of the distribution of easy/hard puzzles? | Just right | | What did you think about the puzzle quality of the test? | Very nice | | What was your opinion about the answer key extraction? | Mostly perfect answer keys | | How did you feel about the length / time limit for this test? | Just right | | Of the puzzles you solved/attempted, how well did the point values reflect the difficulty? | Most puzzles were worth the right amount | | What was your opinion of the booklet formatting and printing? | Just right | |
|
|
An LMI player
| An LMI player posted @ 2013-10-28 10:18 PM How balanced do you think the puzzle types of this test were? | Fairly balanced | | What was your opinion of the distribution of easy/hard puzzles? | Just right | | What did you think about the puzzle quality of the test? | Very nice | | What was your opinion about the answer key extraction? | Mostly perfect answer keys | | How did you feel about the length / time limit for this test? | A bit too many puzzles | | Of the puzzles you solved/attempted, how well did the point values reflect the difficulty? | Most puzzles were worth the right amount | | What was your opinion of the booklet formatting and printing? | Just right | |
|
|
joshuazucker
Posts: 31
![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : United States | How balanced do you think the puzzle types of this test were? | Perfectly balanced | | What was your opinion of the distribution of easy/hard puzzles? | Just right | | What did you think about the puzzle quality of the test? | Very nice | | What was your opinion about the answer key extraction? | Mostly perfect answer keys | | How did you feel about the length / time limit for this test? | Just right | | Of the puzzles you solved/attempted, how well did the point values reflect the difficulty? | Most puzzles were worth the right amount | | What was your opinion of the booklet formatting and printing? | Just right | |
Beautiful theme! Lots of the puzzles were very nice to solve, too, which I know is challenging when the theme constrains the placement of the givens so much. |
|
esther59
Posts: 8
Country : Switzerland | How balanced do you think the puzzle types of this test were? | Fairly balanced | | What was your opinion of the distribution of easy/hard puzzles? | Just right | | What did you think about the puzzle quality of the test? | Very nice | | What was your opinion about the answer key extraction? | Perfect answer keys | | How did you feel about the length / time limit for this test? | Way too many puzzles (too little time) | | Of the puzzles you solved/attempted, how well did the point values reflect the difficulty? | Most puzzles were worth the right amount | | What was your opinion of the booklet formatting and printing? | Just right | |
|
|
Grizix
Posts: 30
![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : France | Grizix posted @ 2013-10-29 6:02 AM How balanced do you think the puzzle types of this test were? | Perfectly balanced | | What was your opinion of the distribution of easy/hard puzzles? | Just right | | What did you think about the puzzle quality of the test? | Average | | What was your opinion about the answer key extraction? | Perfect answer keys | | How did you feel about the length / time limit for this test? | A bit too many puzzles | | Of the puzzles you solved/attempted, how well did the point values reflect the difficulty? | Many puzzles were worth too much or too little | | What was your opinion of the booklet formatting and printing? | I have a different complaint | |
For the booklet complain : the grid was to dark for slitherlink, rectangles and fillomino, it was really hard to draw visible borders onto the printed grid. |
|
debmohanty
![](/images/LMINewLogo.png)
![1000](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/1000.gif) ![500](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/500.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : India | Grizix - 2013-10-29 6:02 AM
For the booklet complain : the grid was to dark for slitherlink, rectangles and fillomino, it was really hard to draw visible borders onto the printed grid.
achan1058 - 2013-10-26 8:33 AM
Maybe it's just my laser printer, but the given lines are dark enough that I have trouble drawing lines on top of the given lines in the slitherlink and fillomino. Certainly agree with that. In fact we recognized all 3 images to be a problem, but didn't get the PB corrected before the test started. I should have notified Matej earlier. Sorry about that.
|
|
chaotic_iak
![](/forum/profile/get-photo.asp?memberid=2069&type=profile&rnd=80) Posts: 241
![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : Indonesia | Yay for Top 20 finish :D /end self bragging
It's interesting that this test has both "Way too many puzzles" and "Way too few puzzles" at the same time. (Also "Too many easy puzzles" and "Too many hard puzzles".) Hm...
Edited by chaotic_iak 2013-10-29 3:25 PM
|
|
macherlakumar
![](/forum/profile/get-photo.asp?memberid=378&type=profile&rnd=880) Posts: 123
![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : India | How balanced do you think the puzzle types of this test were? | Fairly balanced | | What was your opinion of the distribution of easy/hard puzzles? | Just right | | What did you think about the puzzle quality of the test? | Very nice | | What was your opinion about the answer key extraction? | Mostly perfect answer keys | | How did you feel about the length / time limit for this test? | Just right | | Of the puzzles you solved/attempted, how well did the point values reflect the difficulty? | Most puzzles were worth the right amount | |
|
|
detuned
Posts: 152
![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : United Kingdom | detuned posted @ 2013-10-29 7:57 PM prasanna16391 - 2013-10-27 7:16 AM
I still don't understand this, because its like every test. For anyone who can't finish a test, puzzle selection matters. Thats not luck. It would be luck if points distribution was not given and someone went and attempted the Kakuro thinking it to be easy or the Akari thinking they'd get more points for it. But its known which are the lower pointers and the higher pointers, its upto the solver to select the puzzles in a way to optimize their performance. Thats a part of competing. Every Monthly test barring exceptions is typically designed so that the top 3-4 players can finish and there's a few easy puzzles for the rest. In fact, this test has more easy puzzles than others, in my opinion. Its not like 75 minutes is an unheard of time, in fact the ever successful TVCs are also of 75 minutes.
The guidelines LMI gives to the authors was followed here. There were a few easy puzzles, and it was finishable for top solvers. There was never claims that it would be otherwise. Why pinpoint this test on being timed poorly, when it followed the general guidelines?
Obviously, if the discussion is that the general guidelines themselves should be re-visited, then thats a completely different matter. I'll again point to the existence of Beginners' Contests and the need to make the distinction that the Monthly tests are set based on general WPC difficulty and finish-ability.
I think you are missing something here Prasanna, and that is how the points are distributed. Puzzle selection for a competition can indeed come down to luck if you have high variance puzzles (often the case on monthly tests as authors want to show off novel designs and tricks ) or you haven't taken into account a sufficient number of testers. I think that when puzzle selection has a bigger impact on ranking than overall puzzle solving skills then this can cause a lot of frustration, and it would be a mistake for anyone running a competition not to at least consider this issue.
My own personal preference when running a competition is to have more like 20 finishers, and to make sure there are no puzzles with "outlier" levels of difficulty/points distribution which potentially shake things up if you don't solve them or if you attempt to solve them and waste lots of time scoring 0.
I have to say I didn't really find that too much of an issue with this test, which I enjoyed (despite having to solve in paint ); my comments are of a more general nature. |
|
prasanna16391
Posts: 1800
![1000](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/1000.gif) ![500](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/500.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) Country : India | detuned - 2013-10-29 7:57 PM
I think you are missing something here Prasanna, and that is how the points are distributed. Puzzle selection for a competition can indeed come down to luck if you have high variance puzzles (often the case on monthly tests as authors want to show off novel designs and tricks) or you haven't taken into account a sufficient number of testers. I think that when puzzle selection has a bigger impact on ranking than overall puzzle solving skills then this can cause a lot of frustration, and it would be a mistake for anyone running a competition not to at least consider this issue.
Well, if the criticism was about points distribution being off I wouldn't have argued, because most of the time thats down to personal preference. The criticism I argued with was basically that this test was not timed properly.
Obviously it could come down to luck if the distribution is not done right. Points distribution is always an important aspect of organizing a contest. But that comes into relevance only once the choice is made by the participant. Its unfair to say there's luck involved in the selection process itself. You know you are choosing a puzzle thats "supposed to be" high/low difficulty based on points assigned. If it then proves otherwise, its the points distribution that can be criticized, not the timing of the test, which pretty much followed the usual Monthly Test standards (whether the standards are ideal is an entirely different topic ) and any deviation was on the easier side. |
|
achan1058
Posts: 80
![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : Canada | chaotic_iak - 2013-10-29 4:24 AM
Yay for Top 20 finish :D /end self bragging
It's interesting that this test has both "Way too many puzzles" and "Way too few puzzles" at the same time. (Also "Too many easy puzzles" and "Too many hard puzzles".) Hm...
It's simple, really. If you scored well on it (or even that if you have the impression that you did well on it, as I have personally found ), you will find it easy and say that the test should have more puzzles. If you did poorly, you will say the test have too many puzzles. While more experienced contest takers will try to factor out their personal performance in their review, this process isn't perfect. To the more casual contest takers, they aren't going to consider that at all. If they only managed to do 1/4 of the set, of course they are going to say there are way too many puzzles. Edited by achan1058 2013-10-29 10:17 PM
|
|
greenhorn
Posts: 164
![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : Slovakia | Hi everybody,
I am really pleased that Matej fulfilled his promise to prepare a set of puzzles that would make us happy. He often tried to put smiles into his puzzles which sometimes makes me worry because the level of difficulty is closer to tears than to laughter.
In this set, most of the puzzles were human friendly, even though Akari and Masyu where too easy, but in comparism with Kakuro, some easier puzzles were needed. Dispite all, I was not able to finish kakuro within the original time of 60 minutes, and I was a little scared, because only solving the rest of the puzzles took me 58 minutes or so and this does not include printing and submitting answers. That is why we discussed the time limit and finally Deb and Matej have come up with compromise of 75 minutes lenght. From my view, this seemed to be ideal, because 10 puzzlers were able to finnish and 59 puzzlers got the half of points. If we let the initial time limit, Thomas would be the only person to finnish and the rest should have feeling that they participated in badly timed sprint test.
I agree with Deb and some of you, who mentioned the Instant grading, which allows to have a longer competion, but in this case I do not think that adding 30 minutes (instead of 15) will improve the image of this competition - competion full of great and smiling puzzles, do not forget. If some of you were attempted to solve the kakuro and failed, it is not because of bad timing (remember that 10 players have no such problem), but because of revaluation of your skills and bad tactics, which possibly makes the main difference between average players (as me) and the top-solvers.
At the end, I want to express admiration to all contestants, especially to those who finished all the puzzles in time. I am only concerned about the low participation of Slovak puzzlers due to Slovak Puzzle and SudokuTeam Championships held the same weekend. Hope you enjoyed Matej´s puzzles.
Matus |
|
jhrdina
Posts: 8
Country : Czech Republic | jhrdina posted @ 2013-10-30 2:24 AM Very nice
compe tition
Thanks Matej
Jirka |
|
jhrdina
Posts: 8
Country : Czech Republic | jhrdina posted @ 2013-10-30 2:32 AM jhrdina - 2013-10-30 2:24 AM
....Very..........nice...
compe.............tition ..Thanks......Matej... ...........Jirka........
This is what I have intended : ) J. |
|
detuned
Posts: 152
![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : United Kingdom | detuned posted @ 2013-10-30 5:00 PM prasanna16391 - 2013-10-29 3:30 PM
Its unfair to say there's luck involved in the selection process itself. You know you are choosing a puzzle thats "supposed to be" high/low difficulty based on points assigned. If it then proves otherwise, its the points distribution that can be criticized, not the timing of the test, which pretty much followed the usual Monthly Test standards (whether the standards are ideal is an entirely different topic) and any deviation was on the easier side.
OK - lets leave timing of tests out of this discussion, I'm interested in the claim that there is no luck involved in puzzle selection for a test which won't be finished by all but a handful.
I have to disagree with this, to some extent.
For example, what about high variance puzzles? You haven't addressed this despite the fact you will almost certainly have at least one or two of these on every monthly test. It's an interesting topic by itself trying to grade those.
You have to take into account that different people solve puzzles in different ways, and high variance puzzles can amplify the problem. Suppose you had four testers of roughly equal solving ability, who test solved a puzzle in 2 minutes, 5 minutes, 7 minutes and 8 minutes. How many points do you assign the puzzle? The median of 6 minutes seems a good choice, but this is clearly a puzzle which has some intuitive shortcuts, and if you happen to be the right kind of intuitive solver on the test and choose this puzzle, I think it's impossible to argue that you won't be receiving some pretty fortunate points.
The trouble is, if you try and adjust the points total down slightly then you'll probably be undervaluing the puzzle for a lot of other people. Of course things can work out in exactly the same way in the other direction, which can obviously be more frustrating if you you're on the wrong end of things. |
|
prasanna16391
Posts: 1800
![1000](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/1000.gif) ![500](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/500.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) Country : India | I agree with all of this actually. A puzzle, once chosen, can have lucky/unlucky results, depending on solver's strengths vs required logic and a whole lot of other factors.
BUT, again, my main point is that this has to do with points distribution, and something that can be noted only after the puzzles are selected and solved and give out unexpected experiences. It is possible there will be some luck in the puzzle selection. It is also possible that there won't be and all the points are actually pretty accurate, at least for most individuals. The point is, as a solver, no one should go in "expecting" a puzzle to be wrongly valued.
The context here means I wasn't saying luck will never be a factor. I was replying against it being a given that luck will come in during puzzle selection. But, I hope you agree, IF the points are assigned right for an individual, then puzzle selection for that individual becomes more about having their own strengths and strategies. And as a solver, one should go in expecting that to be the case. |
|
motris
Posts: 199
![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : United States | motris posted @ 2013-10-31 12:43 AM Because all individuals solve differently, I'll argue it is impossible to assign points "right" for more than a few individuals on a given test even when we do our best as test-setters. With several test-solvers (Grandmaster Puzzles currently uses about 6-8), you can get a view of consistent puzzle times and high or low variance puzzles but your points are really just a best estimate of the mean value and some puzzles have very wide spreads and some have very small spreads even for individual solvers.
As I see tests, any loop puzzle or number placement puzzle will probably be overvalued for me. Any arithmetic puzzle will probably be undervalued. Looking at this test, for example, I took longer on the Tapa ? (over 3 minutes for 30 points) compared to the Different Neighbours (2.5 minutes for 95 points) and Indirect Yajilin (2.25 minutes for 75 points). Some of this was a mix of good and bad luck but there is quite a difference in returns from this scoring. If I had to leave one of these puzzles unsolved at the end, would I make the right choice? On the other hand the Kakuro took me what looks like 15 minutes for 110 points. I actually feel all those four puzzles were about in the right score range for the general solver (Tapa maybe wanting to be 45). But still, the points do not come close to matching my results.
Tom's point, and mine, is that score/time guidelines are useful but by their very nature imprecise things and hoping for "perfect scoring" will always be a challenge. The fairest ranking of players will always be the time it takes them to complete the entire set of tasks before them. That way solvers will all have cleared the same hurdles, the easy and hard ones, and so if you want a good ranking of 10-50 solvers you should try to get 10-50 solvers to finish the test.
That we had 10 solvers finish is very good and first and second are clear. The effects of different penalty systems will change the order of 3-5 but we have the clearest sense of the relative solving results of these solvers. And no, I am not using the final scores for this comparison. Just the raw times. |
|
joshuazucker
Posts: 31
![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : United States | Changing the subject a lot here ... the puzzles I struggled with the most on this test were Battleship and Different Neighbours, and the Tents I feel like I solved more by guessing/intuition than by really knowing how it was going to work, and none of these were puzzles I ended up submitting during the 75 minutes (I wasted most of my last 15 on failing to solve the neighbors and on failing to count to 6 properly with the snake). Any tips on how to get started on those three puzzles? Once I got a little bit of a start on neighbors (by checking a couple different cases) and on tents (by guessing), I could see how to finish the solve pretty straightforwardly. But that first step was hard/lucky to find.
Back to the original topic, the kakuro took me about the same time as the median of the other puzzles I solved -- in other words, for me it was massively overvalued. The hamle was also some relatively quick points for me. The slitherlink and the tapa took me a lot longer than their point values would suggest, in fact taking almost as long as the kakuro and the hamle took me, certainly way over half the time despite being worth less than half the points. I see, though, that other solvers spent a lot of time on the kakuro, so I'm not suggesting it was valued wrongly, just that there's some combination of strategy and luck in puzzle selection when you're not going to solve all the puzzles.
I used to be able to go into these tests figuring that I wouldn't solve even half of the puzzles, which meant that I could pretty much focus on types I know I'm pretty fast with, and even if it means I end up not looking at a puzzle that's overvalued on average for most solvers, chances are the ones I don't do would turn out to be inefficient for me! Now it seems like I have to plan to at least look at all the puzzles and go for it on the ones that I know how to start quickly, and the strategy/luck is more often in knowing when to give up early vs sticking with a hard puzzle to the end.
Maybe a lot of the variance (luck?) is in the design of the test -- a high-value kakuro is likely to mean some easy points for me, and gains relative to most other solvers, whereas a high-value slitherlink is likely to be a puzzle I don't even try to earn the points on unless I'm in danger of finishing the test. I agree with motris's point that the best measure of my overall solving ability on the test would be the time taken to solve all the puzzles. I may be able to get 2/3 of the points in the allotted time but that doesn't mean I would get all the points in 3/2 of the time! |
|
greenhorn
Posts: 164
![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : Slovakia | joshuazucker - 2013-10-31 1:07 AM
Changing the subject a lot here ... the puzzles I struggled with the most on this test were Battleship and Different Neighbours, and the Tents I feel like I solved more by guessing/intuition than by really knowing how it was going to work, and none of these were puzzles I ended up submitting during the 75 minutes (I wasted most of my last 15 on failing to solve the neighbors and on failing to count to 6 properly with the snake). Any tips on how to get started on those three puzzles? Once I got a little bit of a start on neighbors (by checking a couple different cases) and on tents (by guessing), I could see how to finish the solve pretty straightforwardly. But that first step was hard/lucky to find.
For example, try to solve different neighbours with letters. At the end you will be able to identify which letter stands for which number.
The "eyes" in the tents have only two possiblities - to form a "square" or "tetramino". It is obvious, that one construction should not be used twice. Edited by greenhorn 2013-10-31 1:25 AM
|
|
prasanna16391
Posts: 1800
![1000](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/1000.gif) ![500](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/500.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) Country : India | motris - 2013-10-31 12:43 AM
The fairest ranking of players will always be the time it takes them to complete the entire set of tasks before them. That way solvers will all have cleared the same hurdles, the easy and hard ones, and so if you want a good ranking of 10-50 solvers you should try to get 10-50 solvers to finish the test.
Define "good ranking". Are we then saying that, in this test for instance, the top 10 was a completely fair reflection of skill, but the rest of them were all dependent on luck? Maybe in one test if a person has a bad day due to puzzle selection, then you'd say that one performance was on luck, but that is about the same level of luck as someone solving 9 out of 10 puzzles the fastest, and then getting completely stuck on one to the extent that they can't finish. Over a bunch of tests, both of these factors get negated and generally the rankings turn out fair. Its why in the WSC/WPC the preliminary rounds usually end up being a fair reflection of skill, even though they probably have the same finishing level of top few.
In general, I disagree with this point that a bunch of solvers clearing the same set of tasks minimizes the luck factor. There's always luck involved that a person with the most skill overall still might not spot that one deduction necessary to solve one puzzle. There's also then the choice issue, where you know this test is finish-able and should be done by you, but you're stuck, so do you guess, and then you enter into more luck territory. I made this last point because its the same as a slower solver taking a chip at a high pointer even if they're not sure of finishing within time and then choosing to guess through with time running out. In the end, I just feel both scenarios even out for everyone and its just down to the individual and the relevant competitors having a good or bad day, as it is in most competitive environments. |
|
motris
Posts: 199
![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : United States | motris posted @ 2013-10-31 3:54 AM I'm saying "good ranking" in the sense of robust to changing conditions. Let's say two different test solvers were used for the test, and new scores were applied. Would Murat's 13/15 without Akari and Slitherlink still be better than all of the solvers with 14/15 solved? What if the test ran for 70 minutes. Or 80 minutes. How one sets the rules and scores for a test solvers cannot complete can cause large swings in rank position in these ranks. Regardless of how one sets these things when a test can be finished, the top 10 are basically unaffected. That is what I mean by having a good ranking for those solvers. It doesn't matter if player A was a tester or X was the time and not Y.
To Josh's question -- I definitely found the test rewarded me for being able to sense where intuition and logic would work well. I did use letters with different neighbours to link a whole bunch of cells, but then went to intuition and using uniqueness to get the assignments quickly. The Battleship, surprising enough, was really done by logic which is unusual for the type and made it one of my favorite puzzles. There is a really neat consequence of the logic of the two "1" rows and the two columns with three available spots that each need to take "2"s. Once I caught onto that, it was a much different puzzle.
Edited by motris 2013-10-31 3:55 AM
|
|
prasanna16391
Posts: 1800
![1000](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/1000.gif) ![500](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/500.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) ![100](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/100.gif) Country : India | motris - 2013-10-31 3:54 AM
Regardless of how one sets these things when a test can be finished, the top 10 are basically unaffected.
I actually disagree with this too. It may be just a perception thing, but points do play a role sometimes in how players subconsciously approach the puzzle. If I do a 7 pointer, I'm expecting an easy path. That could derail my run of solving if it turns out to be hard, I get frustrated, and decide either its not worth the points or just put up with it. Whether I finish the test eventually or not, it does cause a slight change in my progress over the test.
I'll give an example - I finished TVC XV. After the previous two, I was expecting to be around that level where if I have a good day I finish, else I'll come up just short. One of the puzzles that really got me stuck was a Double Back Tapa. It was 63 points, which was still a good enough sum for that test to be patient and have a look at it. So I stayed at it without ruining my thought process and needing to change strategy. If it was worth say 30 points, it definitely would not have been worth the waiting, and I now have a choice on whether to stay on it or break my progress and go to a new one. And at least for me, that has resulted in a mistake or two later, in the past.
Maybe some people aren't like that, and just stay the course no matter what, in which case your argument holds true. But that can't be everyone's way. Whether a person finishes or not, they could be affected by points distribution, which could in turn affect the rankings. |
|
David McNeill
Posts: 63
![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : United Kingdom | In the Tents puzzle I assumed that neither of the top 2 patterns could be a square as this would mean a non-unique solution with respect to which tree was connected to which tent. |
|
BohemianCoast
Posts: 16
Country : United Kingdom | I can't see where the password is the booklet this contest, which happened while I was on holiday. I'd like to do the puzzles... am I missing something? |
|
Administrator
![2000](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/2000.gif) ![1000](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/1000.gif) ![500](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/500.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) ![20](https://logicmastersindia.com//forum/images/decorations/multiple/25.gif) Country : India | |
|
BohemianCoast
Posts: 16
Country : United Kingdom | Thank you! |